Research, Evidence & Impact

 
 

Transforming Music Education Through Research, Evidence & Impact

Voices Foundation works with our participants and partners to understand the effectiveness and impact of our work. We incorporate monitoring and evaluation into our programmes, reflect on our learning on an ongoing basis, and undertake specific deep-dive research projects to explore areas of interest further. We then share our findings with our participants, partners, and sector colleagues.

  • Impact Report 2022-23

    Find out what we achieved this year, and the difference we’ve made to so many people. Read our latest Learning & Impact Report.

  • Impact Report 2021-22

    Want to know what difference our work made in 2021-22? Here’s our latest impact report.

  • Theory of Change Diagram

    Want to know how Voices Foundation aims to transform children’s access to high-quality music education? Here is our one-page summary.

  • Theory of Change Narrative

    Want to know more? Read our full Theory of Change.

  • VF Briefing Paper 1

    Music Education in England: Find out about the challenges facing schools-based music education in England and how Voices Foundation’s Singing School programmes can help.

  • VF Briefing Paper 2

    Empowering All Voices: Explore the barriers that stop school staff from singing and read our learning about how these challenges can be overcome.

  • VF Briefing Paper 3

    The Benefits of Music Activity for Disadvantaged Children: Find out what we know about the benefits of music participation for children experiencing disadvantage.

Voices Foundation Impact

Why do we need music? 

  • Music is central to the human experience and present in the everyday lives of people of all ages and cultures (Welch et al., 2020). 

  • Engaging with music may enhance cognitive functions that are key to children's learning, such as planning, working memory, inhibition, and flexibility (Dumont et al., 2017).  

  • Many of the brain functions used when taking part in music are also used by children to achieve key developmental milestones. Speech and music, for example, have several shared processing systems. Musical experiences can impact language perception, which affects learning to read (Hallam, 2010).

  • Studies have found that children who participate in music activities perform better in English, Maths, and Science, regardless of their socioeconomic background and previous academic record. In some cases, the difference between children who do and do not participate in music activity can equate to several months' academic progress (Guhnet al., 2020).

  • Children who participate in long-term musical programmes have shown higher empathy than similar children who do not (Rabinowitchet al. 2013).

  • Through music activity, children can share emotions and express themselves non-verbally. Participating in music activity creates opportunities for children to be heard and it may consequently improve children's self-esteem and confidence to express themselves in non-musical ways too (Mak & Fancourt, 2019).

  • Educators, parents, and guardians can quickly and powerfully communicate instructions or set a mood by giving a musical signal or playing a particular song. As a result, they can use music to help children regulate their behaviour, calm their emotions, or achieve a task more efficiently. This can result in a more productive use of school time, improved focus, and increased learning (Blasco-Magraner, 2021).    

Our approach to Continuing Professional Development and Learning

We believe that all children should have access to high-quality music education that is interactive and engaging. To achieve long-lasting and sustainable change for children, we focus on creating partnerships with those who have the most influence over children's lives: senior school leaders, teachers, parents, and policymakers. Our programmes support non-specialists to develop the knowledge, skills, and confidence to effectively teach and advocate for music. By training one primary school teacher to deliver high-quality music activities in their classroom could benefit up to 900 children throughout that teacher's career! 

We believe our programmes have the most significant impact when we work collaboratively with our partners, establishing a clear, shared vision and working together with a sense of purpose towards the programme outcomes. Our approach stems from research undertaken by Cordingley et al. (2015) about what makes for effective professional development.  Throughout our work, this means that:   

  • Voices Foundation practitioners work collaboratively with participants as peers and co-learners. 

  • We encourage participants who hold leadership roles to actively participate in training and create the conditions for learning to flourish in their workplaces. 

  • The content of our programmes is relevant to participants and their day-to-day experiences and aspirations for pupils. 

  • There are frequent opportunities for everyone to encounter, understand, reflect, and respond to new approaches to practice, successes, and challenges. 

The greatest influence on the quality of children's learning experiences is the quality of teaching [and] the greatest influence on the quality of teaching is the quality of teacher learning experiences.

— Atwal 2019

  • "When I sing, I feel relaxed, and when I have some stress, singing takes it away." 

    What the children say about Voices

  • "I love singing, and it's nice to sing, it calms me down, and it makes my heart glow." 

    What the children say about Voices

  • "I love singing because it makes me feel better at school because it makes me feel that I'm safe and people get to hear my voice." 

    What the children say about Voices

  • "When I sing, I say that I'm brave. I can do whatever I want." 

    What the children say about Voices

  • "There are so many songs that help you to remember stuff… if you need to remember something, think of a small song about it, like a small beat." 

    What the children say about Voices

  • "Sometimes we'll have competitions, who can make the best song about English, who can make the best song about maths, about science, about RE. Or maybe Miss will incorporate it with our learning." 

    What the children say about Voices

  • "It's just really fun to see everyone singing together and smiling and being happy because it's not always like that. Sometimes some of us are sad and down, and suddenly, we're all singing, and we're all lively and happier." 

    What the children say about Voices